In one of the scariest moments in modern history, we're doing our best at ScheerPost to pierce the fog of lies that conceal it but we need some help to pay our writers and staff. Please consider a tax-deductible donation.
Joshua Scheer
As Israel moves to formalize execution as state policy for Palestinians, a chilling new episode of Fronts + Fault Lines traces the colonial legal architecture that made this moment possible. In conversation with Palestinian legal scholar Dr. Nimer Sultany, the hosts expose how Israel’s prison system, military courts, administrative detention regime, and now the so-called “execution bill” are not aberrations — but the continuation of a century-long colonial framework inherited from the British Empire and expanded under Israeli rule.
Sultany delivers a devastating analysis of how torture, imprisonment, and legal repression became foundational tools of domination — from British counterinsurgency tactics in Ireland and Palestine to Israel’s modern prison state. As over 10,000 Palestinians remain imprisoned, many without charge or trial, the episode argues that the new execution bill is not simply another law, but the open legalization of a system critics say has long operated through racialized violence, collective punishment, and impunity.
The discussion dismantles the myth of Israeli “rule of law,” showing how courts, legal scholars, and liberal institutions helped normalize occupation and apartheid while projecting democratic legitimacy abroad. Sultany explains how the same Supreme Court once celebrated internationally as “human rights minded” functioned as a shield for expanding settlements, mass incarceration, torture, and military rule.
Most chillingly, the episode argues that the new death penalty law transforms what was once extremist rhetoric into official state doctrine. “Death to Arabs,” once confined to far-right chants in football stadiums, has now effectively entered Israeli lawmaking itself, according to Sultany’s analysis.
“Death to Arabs Became Law”: New Israeli Execution Bill Sparks Outrage as Scholars Warn of Colonial Legal Escalation
A new Israeli law mandating the death penalty for Palestinians accused of killing Israelis is drawing fierce condemnation from legal scholars, human rights advocates, and Palestinian organizers, who warn the measure represents a historic escalation in Israel’s system of incarceration and colonial control.
In a searing episode of Fronts + Fault Lines from Palestine Deep Dive and the Palestinian Youth Movement, Palestinian legal scholar Dr. Nimer Sultany argues that the bill is not an isolated development, but the culmination of decades of legal structures built to dominate and suppress Palestinians.
“This bill is a culmination of a process,” Sultany explains. “Death to Arabs was a chant… now death to Arabs became law.”
Passed by the Israeli Knesset in the wake of Prisoners’ Day, the law reportedly instructs military courts to impose execution by hanging on Palestinians convicted of killing Israelis, while explicitly denying the same punishment for Israelis convicted of killing Palestinians. The legislation also restricts legal access, limits family visitation, and grants immunity to those carrying out executions.
The episode places the law within a much broader historical framework. Sultany traces the roots of Israel’s prison and military legal system back to the British Mandate, arguing that emergency powers, administrative detention, and expansive military authority were inherited directly from colonial governance structures Britain developed in Palestine, Ireland, India, and elsewhere across its empire.
“What happened in Palestine was never meant to produce self-determination for Palestinians,” Sultany says, describing British rule as a system designed from the start to subordinate the native population while facilitating Zionist colonization.
The conversation also takes aim at the role of Israel’s judiciary, arguing that the country’s Supreme Court and legal establishment helped legitimize occupation and apartheid by giving them the appearance of democratic oversight.
“At the same time the Supreme Court gained a reputation as this activist human rights court,” Sultany notes, “we saw the consolidation of apartheid, increasing brutality of occupation, more settlements, more checkpoints, and more prisoners.”
The hosts and Sultany argue that torture itself has evolved from an “exception” into a governing principle of the prison system. They describe Israel’s network of checkpoints, prisons, military raids, and movement restrictions as creating what scholars increasingly call a “torturous environment” extending far beyond prison walls into everyday Palestinian life.
The episode arrives amid growing international scrutiny of Israel’s detention regime, particularly after October 2023, when reports of widespread torture, starvation, medical neglect, and deaths in custody intensified. Sultany argues that the execution bill formalizes what many Palestinians already experience: a system designed not merely to incarcerate resistance, but to eradicate it.
“Now torture is not simply to suppress resistance under apartheid,” he says. “Now torture is to destroy under genocide.”
For the hosts, the fight over prisoners remains central to the broader Palestinian struggle itself. Palestinian prisoners, they argue, are not marginal figures but the “human engine” of Palestinian political consciousness and resistance — one reason they remain such a central target of Israeli state policy.
As outrage over the law spreads internationally, the episode warns that what is unfolding is not simply a legal debate, but a transformation of racialized violence into codified state doctrine — one whose consequences could reverberate far beyond Palestine itself.
Editor’s Note: At a moment when the once vaunted model of responsible journalism is overwhelmingly the play thing of self-serving billionaires and their corporate scribes, alternatives of integrity are desperately needed, and ScheerPost is one of them. Please support our independent journalism by contributing to our online donation platform, Network for Good, or send a check to our new PO Box. We can’t thank you enough, and promise to keep bringing you this kind of vital news.
You can also make a donation to our PayPal or subscribe to our Patreon.
Please share this story and help us grow our network!
